| Fall 2005 Sport Awards | ||
| Football | DJ Ballinger | OCC Honorable Mention |
| Cody Beatty | OCC 1st Team | |
| Brandon Burton | Comet Award | |
| Tony Jackson | OCC 1st Team, Joseppi's Defensive Player of the Year | |
| David Kanode | 4th Year Varsity | |
| Vaughn Klein | OCC 2nd Team | |
| Matt Lindsey | OCC Scholar Athlete | |
| Chris Lowe | OCC 2nd Team | |
| Aaron Mickens | OCC 2nd Team, Joseppi's Offensive Player of the Year | |
| Shane Usner | OCC 1st Team | |
| Boys Soccer | Ayoub Abouchahine | Coaches Award |
| Kyle Haning | Comet Award | |
| Nick Kadoves | OCC 1st Team, District 3rd Team | |
| Shaun Raugh | OCC Honorable Mention | |
| Jeremy Solberg | OCC 2nd Team | |
| Adam Taylor | Defensive Player of the Year | |
| Girls Soccer | Christina Browning | OCC 1st Team, Defensive Player of the Year |
| Brittany Doherty | OCC 1st Team, OCC Scholar Athlete, 4th Year Varsity, Most Valuable Player | |
| Jennifer Fowler | OCC Honorable Mention, Heart and Hustle Award | |
| Amy Marshall | 4th Year Varsity | |
| Christine Ward | OCC 2nd Team | |
| Girls Tennis | Amanda Blake | OCC Honorable Mention, Most Wins Award |
| Danielle Butler | 4th Year Varsity | |
| Whitney Holbrook | OCC Honorable Mention, Most Wins Award | |
| Michelle Meyer | Comet Award | |
| Maria Wood | OCC Honorable Mention | |
| Cross Country | Brianna Barber | OCC 1st Team, District 1st Team, Big Impact Award |
| Brooke Bohanan | OCC 1st Team, District 1st Team, "The Rock" Award | |
| Alex Jordan | OCC 1st Team, District 1st Team, OCC Scholar Athlete, | |
| " " | OATCCC All-Ohio Academic, 4th Year Varsity, Dedication Award | |
| Lakeeya Jordan | OCC 2nd Team, District 1st Team | |
| Rebecca Koch | OCC Honorable Mention, "I Bleed Silver & Blue" Award | |
| Samantha Meadows | OCC 2nd Team | |
| Corey Roberts | OCC 1st Team, District 1st Team | |
| Michael Tran | "Positive Mental Attitude" Award | |
| Daniel Tucker | OCC 2nd Team, "What a Difference a Year Makes" Award | |
| Volleyball | Mandy Fannin | Most Improved Player |
| Nicole Miller | OCC Honorable Mention, OCC Scholar Athlete | |
| Andrea Moore | OCC 2nd Team, 4th Year Varsity, Coaches Award | |
| Laurie Shives | OCC 1st Team, District 1st Team, Most Valuable Player Award | |
| Cheerleaders | Katrina King | Shooting Star Award |
| Jill Stoneking | Outstanding Comet Award | |
| Kristin Wonder | Spirited Comet Award | |